So, Prosers, the playoffs are off and running. Giving more words was a good idea – the concepts are fleshed out here and everything – but the theme was a bit of a killer. There’s nothing bad here, but it was obviously a tougher one for the writers (and I know this because three of the four told me so).
So, two of you have been great, but your journeys end here. The others have the daunting task of taking on Ian and Sarah for Friday’s deadline. Let’s sort this out.
1 Bret Highum
I’ve always been a history buff, so I didn’t have to think about it for very long when Professor Obata offered me a chance to try out his new Virtual Historical Gamer. A quick tutorial and some uncomfortable plumbing hookups, and away I went!
My cheek rasps softly against the wooden stock as I nestle it into my shoulder. The trigger seems to tremble under the touch of my finger, the cool metal begging me to add a couple ounces of pressure to release the firing pin. I try to calm my breathing, but this is so realistic!
The sky is beginning to lighten, the sun cresting over the hill in front of me. Beautiful. I wait until the Targets appear, black silhouettes in front of a creamy pink backdrop slashed with orange. I apply pressure to the trigger, just enough, repeatedly. The Targets go down.
I ignore the shooting from either side of me; undisciplined spurts of gunfire that tend to find red clay or whistle off into the atmosphere. One of the Non-Targets is huddled in the mud next to my feet, screaming in terror. Too much realism. I ignore it until my rifle is too hot for me to hold. Then I take the Non-Target’s rifle and ammunition and go back to shooting.
I get into a rhythm as the sun climbs higher and I can see more clearly. There is a small group of Targets carrying an American flag. One shot for each. A Target hides between a tree and a boulder. I shoot the rock face; then shoot the Target when the rock chips spalling from the shattered pumice drive the target into the open. The firing from my allies has become nearly stopped. A Target crawling back to the top of the ridge. One shot.
Now it gets trickier. The Non-Targets are starting to move forward, and I have to be careful to not hit them. Someone behind me starts yelling at me, but I ignore it. There are more Targets, and I only have so much time. I manage to hit two of them before I am tackled from behind and my rifle taken away.
The Non-Targets release me when I don’t struggle. Once their attention leaves me, I key the recall switch held between my upper molars.
“So, how’d it work?” asked Doctor Obata, as he unhooked the feeds and opened the clamshell of the immersion tank.
I stretch my neck- that had been very intense. “Good, good. What was that, Iwo Jima? Very realistic, maybe a bit too gory. A little uncomfortable being on the Japanese side, but the past is the past, right?”
Doctor Obata’s eyes glitter a bit, and his smile is merely thin lips drawn back tight from yellowed teeth. I have my jacket on and I’m halfway to the door before I realize all the voices I hear through the open windows are speaking Japanese and the flag by the blackboard is white with a red circle.
K: This isn’t a bad idea, but it’s pretty clear where it’s going from early on. I’ve become trained to look for big endings, and this was the only one that made sense, given Doctor Obata’s name. I liked the prose, but the structure needed a bit of work. BRONZE
P: I’m a bit conflicted with this one on first read. The change in tenses throws me out of it a little, even though it was obviously purposefully done. The concept is solid, and the parallels of mindless first person shooter playing (where people are delineated into “targets” and “non-targets”) raise it a cut above what it could have been. The ‘gotcha!’ ending, then, seems to let the story off too easy. It’s clever, but I’m unsure of whether or not it truly fits.
2 Erik S
Raymond had loaded the washer, but not started the cycle. His wife, Joan, after her nightly gin(s), needed little excuse to berate him to madness. After the usual, useless row, he slammed himself inside the study. Seizing on an outlet, he ripped apart a subordinate’s budget proposal that was innocuously sitting in his inbox…
David glared at his computer screen the next morning, bristling at the rebuke. What would that old bastard know about how things really were? Forcefully closing his laptop, he walked to one of his salesman’s desk and demanded his recent call report. Glancing at, and summarily dismissing it, he noisily criticized such shoddy work loud enough for anyone within earshot to hear it…
After picking up his son, Garrett sulked at the restaurant table, still sour over the afternoon’s events. His son sensed the weather and quietly picked at his food. Returning to fill his soda a little later than he would have liked, Garrett took the opportunity to belittle a frequent target of everyone: the waitress. He loudly wondered how a job like this could possibly be so difficult. Through clenched teeth, the waitress apologized, retreated to the wait station, and impatiently glanced at the clock…
Returning home to her apartment after her double shift, Barbara removed the shoes from her aching feet, hung up her coat, dropped her purse, and fell into a chair beside the kitchen table. Her son, further and further distant these last couple years, grunted a greeting, and stuck his head in the fridge. Barbara sighed deeply. Normally, Barbara said little to nothing, but tonight, she just felt she couldn’t hold back. “Son,” she said…
—
I closed the door and turned around. “Yeah?”
“I… I’m sorry.”
“F… for what?” I asked, slightly unnerved.
“We… I… I don’t know, I guess we don’t talk so much these days. I usually come home too tired from work, and you’re usually busy with this or that. I just…”
And then she gave a tired, little laugh, took a deep breath and asked, “How was your day?”
“It was okay.”
She exhaled quietly, softly nodded her head, and gently said, “Good. I’m glad to hear that, honey.” She saw me glance at my room and said, “Sorry. Long day. Anyway, if you need anything, let me know.”
“…Okay”, I muttered. I took two steps towards my room, stopped, and for what I realized was the first time in a long time, said, “Thanks, Mom.”
—
I think that was the first time I saw my mother for what she was: a hard working woman who had sacrificed more than I ever knew for me after what I’ve discerned was a bastard of father left her years ago. I only wished it hadn’t taken me 15 years to reach that realization. I’m not sure what inspired her to reach out to me, in her own little way that night, but looking back, I think that’s my one of my last days as a kid, and one of my first days as a man.
K: I really like this idea and payoff, but the change in perspective is odd, to say the least. It’s told in third person omniscient initially, and then in each of the other two sections, it’s in first. It’s a strange decision, and unfortunate, since otherwise I really liked the scope of this story. SILVER
P: At first, it seems as though we’ve stumbled upon some sort of horrible reversal of paying it forward. Then, the twist – a happy one. The halting dialogue is a bit much, but that’s a minor gripe. I was dreading the payoff to this one, expecting everything to pick up steam until in culminated in all out death and destruction, but instead, I got an inspiring story without a lot of saccharine.
SILVER
3 David Larson
Sept. 23, 1999
Mars loomed large in front of the Mars Climate Orbiter as it sped towards its rendezvous. After gliding through space for 286 days, MCO had finally reached the critical point in its journey where the orbit insertion burn would occur. Unfortunately, the orbiter was 100 kilometers closer to Mars that it should have been, and its struggling engines overheated in the Martian atmosphere. Instead of slowing into an ever-decreasing parabolic orbit, it plowed across the thin atmosphere and escaped Mars’ gravity to be lost for good.
Jan. 13, 1997
Jeff Kehler, a software engineer with Lockheed Martin, relaxed in his Colorado home, a remote in his hand. He had scrolled through most of the cable channels when he stumbled upon a rerun of the first episode of Cosmos. He was pretty sure he hadn’t seen it since it first ran back when he was in college, so he settled down for a little guilty pleasure. When the episode ended, it was followed immediately by the second episode, and Jeff realized that it was aCosmos marathon! After the seventh episode, Jeff changed and got into bed, and while he knew he had final integration testing tomorrow, he also knew that his VCR wasn’t working, so he continued to stay awake, finally shutting off the TV after the last episode, at almost 4AM.
Sept. 27, 1999
While internal mission analysis had already begun, an external “MCO Failure Board” was formally commissioned. When a $125 million project fails, fingers need to be pointed. The folks at JPL in Pasadena were convinced it was the navigation software from Lockheed Martin, while the Lockheed Martin engineers in Colorado were sure it was the operations of the JPL scientists that caused the error.
Jan. 14, 1997
Jeff Kehler snapped awake in his chair in the test lab, the integration testing already well underway. He quickly tried to remember at what point he was at when he fell asleep, but could not recall for sure. In any case, the other testers were at lunch, and with a couple quick calculations he could tell that the simulation was already showing a noticeable discrepancy, no doubt due to his failure to apply the expected mid-mission flight corrections. After waffling a bit, he quickly overrode test protocols and made a manual course correction before the others returned. He then decided he’d better pause the simulation to get some coffee. The remainder of the day’s simulation completed within test tolerances.
Nov. 10, 1999
MCO Failure Board released their phase 1 report describing the probable cause of the mission failure. It was determined that a systemic failure of communication between NASA’s JPL and Lockheed Martin, specifically the use of metric versus English measuring systems, was the root cause. Deeper in the report it faulted the integration testing for failing to identify the discrepancy prior to launch. What the report failed to ultimately uncover, though, was that the blame for the huge setback to the exploration of Mars fell directly upon the late Carl Sagan.
K: I love this one all over. Yes, it’s a gimmicky structure that totally works as a storytelling device and yes, the science is interesting, but there’s more than that. This is a human story about an eager character with very important shortcomings, and how those flaws affect his life and career. So many sci-fi writers forget to ask their readers to connect with a character or with a real story; this writer – and we all know who it is – NEVER forgets to do that. GOLD
P: Heh, funny. I like the back and forth narration of this story, and the joke at the end is definitely good. The perils of staying up well past one’s supposed bedtime come through time and again, though rarely with such catastrophic results. This may be the best pure example of the challenge.
BRONZE
4 Matt Novak
In the beginning, Rube Goldberg needed a light.
He spent the better part of his first day trying to find the right size bulbs for the warehouse he’d rented. And then he needed to find a really tall step ladder. But when he got the lights in, it was good.
The next day, Rube had to decide where he’d set up his machine. The machine had lots of parts. He’d need a staging area. A haven, for planning, away from the chaos. So on the second day, Rube created the havens.
On the third day, when Rube got to the warehouse, he found it had been flooded. So he got out a mop, and made some dry floor in the midst of the water, and that was good.
On day four of building his machine, Rube strung up all the various lights he’d use, that would switch on and off, and mark the times that various things were happening. And that was pretty good too.
On the fifth day, Rube really got down to work. He hung some of parts of his invention from the rafters, and used some of the spots where there was still water too. The invention was really coming together, and it was good.
On the sixth day, Rube Goldberg finished his machine. It quickly grew and multiplied and came to fill the warehouse. And then he created his pièce de résistance, a part of the machine in his image and likeness, and he set it over all the rest of his invention. And he looked over everything he had done, and it was really, really good.
On the seventh day, Rube went down to the warehouse. He was going to set his machine in motion. Just a little flick would set a marble rolling, and bit by bit all the pieces would move, the whole thing in motion, so much greater than the small beginning. He had created an entire system: complex and interconnected and beautiful. But when he got there he remembered that he was supposed to pick up his grandmother and take her to Uncle Morty’s for dinner. They were having brisket. He rushed away, the keys still in the door. He would have gone back, but he wouldn’t have ever heard the end of it if he’d been late with gramgrams, and it was a small thing, leaving the place unlocked.
It was a restful day, and for a time he forgot all about his invention.
On day eight, Rube came back. Things were a mess. It seems someone with bad intentions – some little devil – had come by and mucked things up. The machine was running, but it certainly wasn’t behaving like Rube had intended. Wheels were spinning, fires were burning, and various factions kept crashing into others.
Tempted to forget the whole thing, Rube remembered his motivation.
“Alright,” he said to himself, “but if Rube Junior wants to see this work, he’s going to have to help me clean it up.”
K: Cute enough, even if the gimmick wears itself out before long. The theme seems tacked on, which is okay for broad comedy like this, I suppose. I think it can be pretty funny, but the gags needed to be punched up to drive the absurdity home.
P: So, I guess ‘clever’ is a descriptor that could work for pretty much all of these (lots of thinking outside the box!), but a Rube Goldbergian semi-retelling of the Genesis creation account? That’s fantastic. Puns are plentiful, but all of them are sharp and smart, and the ending is pure gold. In fact, this whole story is.
GOLD
———————————————-
After two straight weeks of Pete and I agreeing on practically everything, we can’t get together here. No harm done, right? Well, not unless you’re Novak. Ahem.
So, Erik S and David Larson hereby move to the semifinals. Sorry to keep you around when you tried to leave, Erik.
They’ll join Sarah Johnson and Ian Pratt for the penultimate challenge: due Friday, with a limit of 500 words, write a story where the central character has a month or less to live, and knows it.
Thanks for the season, Novak and Bret. I’ll write a more proper goodbye tomorrow, but damn, I am tired tonight.
29 comments
Comments feed for this article
October 2, 2012 at 1:38 am
AMR
Another one? Sonofa…
I haven’t even finished the last one.
October 2, 2012 at 1:38 am
nibbish
So. I gold Novak on the challenge that gets him eliminated? There’s a certain level of irony to that, I think.
October 2, 2012 at 1:42 am
mbnovak
Absurdism seemed to be the name of the game for me in this format.
October 2, 2012 at 6:54 am
Rhubarb_Runner
Oh geez, I had already emptied my locker and gotten out the golf bag…
October 2, 2012 at 7:00 am
Spookymilk Play With The Prose — Playoff Challenge #1: Small Decision/Huge Consequences | "é rayhahn, rayhahn"
[…] Will there be a “next week” or not? RESULTS […]
October 2, 2012 at 8:09 am
Rhubarb_Runner
Philo, that opening line is great 🙂
October 2, 2012 at 10:17 am
mbnovak
Thanks. I got really excited writing this one.
October 2, 2012 at 10:39 am
freealonzo
While I would have medaled them a little differently, imho the best two submissions are moving forward.
October 2, 2012 at 11:59 am
bhiggum
Yup, I struggled with this one. It’s hard to come up with a small decision that leads directly to a huge consequence without other, larger decisions in between. Also, I learned that if you write a crappy paragraph but keep it because you can’t come up with any better ideas, be happy if you end up with a bronze.
Congrats to David and Erik! Looking forward to reading the stories coming up!
October 2, 2012 at 12:35 pm
hungry joe
one of several ideas i was playing around with was an alien race intercepting either a pioneer or voyager craft and, either being unintentionally slighted by something on it (like the man’s raised hand being an insult, etc.), or just using the pulsar map to find and harvest/destory earth, or something like that.
2 stories boiling to carl sagan this week would have been something.
October 2, 2012 at 2:31 pm
freealonzo
I would done something along the lines of David Lee Roth taking one of Michael Anthony’s sandwiches from the fridge, leading to a late night run to Taco Bell where Michael, Eddie, and Alex run into Sammy Hagar.
October 3, 2012 at 7:32 am
Rhubarb_Runner
Hmmm, how about the alien race upset because the gold disk didn’t include a Van Halen song? Two birds <– one stone!
October 3, 2012 at 9:55 am
freealonzo
Throw some sodomy in there and then I’d really be cooking with gas!
October 3, 2012 at 3:52 pm
punmanbowler
Matt, great story. I don’t know what Spooky’s problem was, but I thought it was brilliant, especially as a Bible Reader. The last line just brought it all home.
October 3, 2012 at 3:56 pm
spookymilk
You don’t know what my “problem” was? Huh. If only I’d written a critique of it somewhere that clearly outlined why I wasn’t all that into it.
I’ve actually read the Bible, too. Three or four times. That didn’t make the idea any less tiring for me as it went on. It seems like you’re suggesting my problem was not being into the religious aspect of it, but I have on a regular basis given high scores to stories with a religious bent.
October 3, 2012 at 4:01 pm
mbnovak
Heck, he usually gives high scores to my stories with a religious bent.
That said, I’m not sure what his problem was either. 😉
October 3, 2012 at 4:02 pm
spookymilk
Exactly! “Martyr” is one of my favorite stories, ever and anywhere.
October 3, 2012 at 4:58 pm
nibbish
That says quite a bit for “Hapax Legomenon”, then.
October 3, 2012 at 5:13 pm
spookymilk
It certainly does, although if I looked at them today I’d probably pick Martyr (though, of course, I have the benefit of knowing which of them would stick in my head more completely).
They both won Immunity, so no harm done…that is, unless Brooks was supposed to be eliminated that week.
Which season were those? VIII?
October 3, 2012 at 5:28 pm
nibbish
Yup, VIII. It’s funny what sticks and what doesn’t from some of those seasons. Martyr sticks, Brooks’ final submission stands out. Shawn’s Fiction 59. DK’s “Russian cat murderer”. Brooks’ EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE story. Those are the five I remember.
October 3, 2012 at 5:34 pm
spookymilk
A lot of stories stick in my head, but I’ve been doing this for so long that I routinely (especially with recent seasons) forget which stories were in which season, and sometimes even forget what the challenge was. I always remember the authors, though.
Occasionally, I even forget which challenge is which (even if I named the challenges). Last season, I ran the Rashomon challenge when I meant to run the Dirty Harry challenge. I would have just changed it, but I’d told the finalists days earlier that I was running Rashomon. The themes (and films!) are nothing alike outside of the fact that both have tremendous cinematography, so there’s really no good reason that I forgot which was which for so long.
I do tend to remember challenges in the pure strategic seasons, but once I’ve done a bunch of these seasons I’m sure my memory for those will fade too.
October 3, 2012 at 5:35 pm
spookymilk
Another funny thing: the stories that stick with me most from VIII and X are Novak’s “Martyr” and John Wreisner’s “Brazen Bull.” I gave neither of them Immunity. Well, live and learn.
October 3, 2012 at 5:42 pm
nibbish
Yeah, you told me you were running Rashomon so that I could hurry through two challenges in one night so that I wouldn’t nonsub on my trip to Mexico, since I was going to be completely off grid for the exact days of both the challenge and the elimination.
October 3, 2012 at 6:37 pm
mbnovak
And that was the lamest Rashomon challenge ever.
Also, yes, Brooks was supposed to go that week. Actually, in all seriousness, he was supposed to go the week of the question/answer challenge, but since I didn’t have immunity I wasn’t going to trust Dean.
The ones from VIII that stick out to me are Brooks’ and Shawn’s Fiction 59, Swingtack, Pete’s Useless superpower, Shawn’s Meeting of the Mimes, and, for myself, both Martyr and Lunch not Launch. That was the challenge where I finally figured out how to write, at least a little bit, so it really sticks with me.
October 3, 2012 at 7:22 pm
nibbish
I forgot Swingtack was from VIII. Also, yeah, Brooks’ fiction 59 was pretty great. He probably should’ve won that season for how well he did.
October 3, 2012 at 10:12 pm
mbnovak
Suck it, Nibs.
October 3, 2012 at 8:30 pm
freealonzo
he was supposed to go the week of the question/answer challenge, but since I didn’t have immunity I wasn’t going to trust Dean.
Son of a…..
One that I will never forget was Carter Hayes rough sex submission. I hate myself for liking that one so much.
October 3, 2012 at 10:13 pm
mbnovak
I probably wasn’t going to trust you regardless of your entry, but it certainly didn’t help.
October 4, 2012 at 8:36 am
freealonzo
It’s cool. Provided me with loads of faux indignation and a fun writing topic, I’ve milked that sucker for over a year now.